How insurance brokers get more car insurance clients
Brokerages win new car insurance clients in five main ways: following up on renewal dates, referrals, showing up in search, running social ads, and appearing on comparison sites. The first four can stay in the brokerage's own name. In Ontario, any arrangement that pays an outside party per referral has to fit RIBO's referral fee rules.
1. Renewal dates
Most drivers only shop when their policy is about to renew. Knowing a prospect's renewal date tells you when to call. In Ontario, RIBO's guidelines allow unlicensed staff to collect expiry dates as long as they give no insurance advice and pass every insurance question to a licensed broker.
2. Referrals from clients and partners
Happy clients refer family and friends. Partners refer too, but in Ontario a broker may pay referral fees only to certain financial intermediaries, such as mortgage brokers and real estate brokers, and only with the client's written consent first. See what the RIBO rules say.
3. Search
Drivers search for car insurance quotes in their city. Large comparison sites take most of those searches, so a single brokerage usually does better on local searches, its Google Business Profile and reviews than on broad national terms.
4. Social ads
Ads on Facebook and Instagram reach drivers before they search. They work best with a short quote form and a fast callback. RIBO's guidelines say a broker on social media must clearly identify the registered brokerage. This is the channel our program runs for brokerages, under the brokerage's own name. See how it works.
5. Comparison sites
Comparison sites show a driver several prices at once. They bring volume, but the driver is comparing you with other brokers and insurers from the first click.
Side by side
| Channel | Whose name the driver sees | Typical cost |
|---|---|---|
| Renewal follow up | Yours | Staff time |
| Referrals | Yours | Service, plus any allowed referral fee |
| Search | Yours | Time, or a monthly agency fee |
| Social ads | Yours | Ad spend plus management |
| Comparison sites | Shown next to competitors | Set by the site |
Sources
- Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario, Guidelines on Marketing Practices (June 2016): ex-dating, referral fees and social media.
Read on November 20, 2026. This guide is general information, not legal advice.
Next: which provinces have private car insurance. Or Apply for your area